On January 21, 1998, in Amarillo, Texas, Balentine fatally shot three young men - 17-year-old Edward Mark Caylor, 15-year-old Kai Brooke Geyer and 15-year-old Steven Brady Watson, once each in the head with a 32-caliber pistol. Balentine entered the residence during the night and committed the murders while the victims were sleeping.
Source: Texas Department of Criminal Justice